When Disability Stigma Causes Disability
When Disability Stigma Causes Disability

Categories: Health

By Guest Blogger Peter Kronenberg, Vice President for Communications, the National Association of People with Aids

Thirty-one years ago, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported cases of a new disease we now know as AIDS – Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome. 

This week, the nineteenth International AIDS Conference meets in Washington, D.C. There’s hope in the air. For the first time, HIV/AIDS scientists, clinicians and policy makers think it may be possible to bring America’s HIV epidemic to an end. 

We’ve made remarkable scientific and medical progress against HIV. Three decades after those first cases, we now know what causes AIDS: a previously unknown virus, identified and given the name human immunodeficiency virus, or, more commonly, HIV. We now have medicines that don’t permanently cure the virus, but keep it under control for most people who take their medications as prescribed. Today, people with HIV can lead normally healthy lives with nearly normal life expectancies. 

We’ve made epidemiological progress, too. We know today that people whose HIV is fully suppressed are radically less likely to pass their infections on to others. In principle, near-universal testing and treatment could make new HIV infections almost a thing of the past. 

And yet new infections keep coming – an estimated 50,000 a year for half a decade now, despite the scientific and epidemiological progress. 

Maybe it’s time to start thinking of HIV infection as a disability again, as we did in the years before we had effective medicines. 

HIV infection is still a disability because of stigma. All of us who live with disabilities know how quickly stigma follows the perception that we are “different.” School children taunt classmates with motor disabilities. Adults talk to other adults in wheelchairs as if they were five-year-olds. 

Living with HIV is a disability like any other in the opportunity it gives others to see us as “different.” 

It may be unique, however, in being a disability that is actually caused by stigma. 

HIV spreads mostly – let’s be frank – by sexual contact. There are communities in America where talking realistically about sex is deeply taboo. The result is that too many Americans don’t know they are at risk, because they think HIV infection only happens to “those people” – whatever we mean by those people. Too many Americans don’t know that most new HIV infections happen where there are already high numbers of undetected, untreated infections. Too many Americans think you have to be promiscuous or sinful to get infected, and would rather risk dying of untreated HIV than get tested and know for sure that they themselves had just become “those people.” 

A majority – possibly as many as three-quarters – of all new HIV infections in this country come from the 20 percent of Americans with HIV who don’t know they are infected. They don’t know because they are afraid to know. We are literally dying of shame. 

As the nineteenth International AIDS Conference meets this week in Washington, we expect news of exciting medical breakthroughs. HIV may become fully curable sooner than we ever thought possible. 

But the HIV epidemic won’t end until we face down the stigma – the unlovely but basic human impulse to define ourselves up by defining others down – that goes with living with HIV and so many other disabilities.

Get tested. Visit the CDC’s National HIV and STD Testing Resources website to find a testing site near you. Also, visit NAPWA.org for more resources on what to do if you test positive.

4 Responses to When Disability Stigma Causes Disability

  1. Paul says:

    Disabilities of ANY physical sort can cause stigma. I usually don’t tell anyone about my back & shoulder problems unless someone asks me to move something heavy or asks why I don’t ski, jump, run. etc.

  2. Aidel says:

    Being disabled for (lack of) mental health is also very stigmatizing. When I am in a position in which I must tell someone I’m disabled, they scoff and say “What’s wrong with you? You look OK to me?” This wouldn’t be said to someone in a wheelchair. Indeed most people won’t ask physically handicapped persons “What’s wrong with you?”

    • Ibrahim says:

      Never, under any circumstances, procrastinate about asking for a HIV/STD/STI test. Your doctor is not allowed to discuss any medical history with another member of your family, or within/outside of their practice without your consent. Doing so can lead to the practice being sued for breach of privacy amongst other charges. Ask your doctor for a test, they should direct you where to go get your blood/urine tests. If you’re afraid to ask your doctor outright for an HIV test, mask it within a bunch of other tests, and should he/she ask you why you want a HIV test, casually say that you are sexually active and want to maintain your health and well being. Should the test be positive, the doctor will have no choice and will need to notify your health department. The tests usually take approximately 3 days and results are delivered to your doctor.

  3. dkmnow says:

    This is not unique at all.

    Please go to Wikipedia and look up “Social model of disability.”

    The debilitating effects of stigma and structural discrimination surrounding disabilities of ALL kinds are well acknowledged in sociology and especially the academic discipline of disability studies. Indeed, there are now numerous variants on the “social model” theme, with many insights to offer into how & why both disabled and differently-abled are so ill-served by society at large.

    Stigma is ALWAYS a debilitating factor — sometimes the PRIMARY factor — in impairing or destroying quality of life, no matter what condition or classification it attaches to. No exceptions.